Copart and IAAI lots that sell below market: what 144,000 sales show
One lot in ten sells at 65% of its modelled price or less. We modelled 143,989 US sales and found which pre-sale signals raise that share: listing age, sale type, seller, yard state, weekday and damage labels.

One sold lot in ten at Copart and IAAI goes for 65% of its modelled price or less. We modelled 143,989 US sales from six weeks and looked at which pre-sale signals predict that outcome: the numbers, two tables and a checklist.
The question and the baseline
For every sold car the model estimates what it should have fetched given make, model, year, trim, odometer, damage, title, run status, keys, airbags and site. A "deal" is a sale in the bottom decile of the residual, i.e. at no more than 0.65x the modelled price. By definition that is 10% of sales. The question is which listing signals raise that share.
| Signal | Sales | Price vs model | Deal rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| IAAI live auction, listed 21+ days | 2,774 | 0.86x | 23% |
| IAAI live auction, listed 28+ days | 1,507 | 0.84x | 26% |
| IAAI, listed 21+ days, dealer seller | 1,196 | 0.78x | 31% |
| NE/WV/AL/MI/OH yard, IAAI auction, listed 14+ days | 814 | 0.82x | 28% |
| Car 10+ years old, live auction, dealer seller | 10,158 | 0.94x | 20% |
| Copart, listed 10–35 days | 7,537 | 0.99x | 15% |
| Buy Now (either site) | 20,767 | 1.08x | 4% |
| Timed (IAAI) | 6,041 | 1.05x | 5% |
| Classifier, top 5% of score (AUC 0.73) | 7,200 | 0.83x | 30% |
Try the calculation yourself
Change the bid and see delivery, fees, and customs in a working demo. No registration needed.
No sign-up. Explore the example without saving changes.
Listing age: the strongest lever
Price falls steadily after about 10 days on site. The effect is clearest at IAAI: live-auction lots listed 21 days or longer closed at a median 0.86x the modelled price, and 23% were deals. From 28 days, 0.84x and 26%. With a dealer seller, 0.78x and 31%, three times the baseline. At Copart the effect is milder: lots aged 10–35 days closed at 0.99x, though the deal rate still reached 15%.
Sale type: only live auctions produce deals
Buy Now on either site closed at 1.08x the modelled price with a 4% deal rate; IAAI's Timed auction at 1.05x and 5%. Live auctions are the only format that produces below-market sales; the formats are explained in our guide to Copart sale types.
Who is selling
Dealer and consignment lots produce 1.4x the deal rate of insurance lots. Finance and repo sellers (Bridgecrest, OneMain, TitleMax), charities and car-buying services produce 1.4–2x. Lots from Progressive, State Farm Group, Bristol West and Farmers rarely go cheap. The large slice "car 10+ years old, live auction, dealer seller" (10,158 sales) gives 0.94x and a 20% deal rate.
Relists
A single relist changes nothing. Three or more raise the deal rate by about 1.5x. Relists still sell 13–21% above the previous attempt's rejected bid: the bid the seller turned down is a floor, not a ceiling. The numbers from 2,000 VIN chains are in our piece on the rejected bid at Copart.
Geography
Yards in RI, ME, NH, VT, CT, NY, MA, WV, AL, MI and OH sell 2–5% below the model; the strongest effects are at Hartford, Detroit, Syracuse, Buffalo, Exeter RI and Cleveland East. The slice "IAAI auction, yard in those states, listed 14+ days" gives 0.82x and a 28% deal rate. Hawaii shows 0.61x, but that is the cost of shipping off the island, not a deal.
Day and time of the sale
At IAAI, Tuesday and Wednesday are 3% cheaper than Monday and Friday. Weekend and evening sales are 5–10% dearer; the first morning slots are cheaper than the rest of the day.
Thin listings
Lots with no video, no 360°, no odometer reading or fewer than 14 photos at IAAI do not sell cheaper at the median, but their price spread is wider: 1.5–1.7x more sales far below market. Some buyers skip them because they are hard to assess.
Who buys the deals: buyers from the USA, El Salvador, Iraq and Guatemala. Ukrainian buyers paid on average 1% more than the modelled price, Georgian buyers 5% more.
What the market over-discounts and over-pays for
A model without condition variables shows how much the market takes off or adds for each label, relative to the same cars without it.
| Over-discounted | Price | Over-paid | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rollover | 0.54x | Hail | 1.66x |
| Burn / Burn engine | 0.60x / 0.65x | Minor dent/scratches | 1.37x |
| All Over | 0.67x | Clean / original title | 1.24–1.59x |
| Non-repairable / CoD | 0.53–0.81x | Theft recovery | 1.26x |
| Stationary (vs Run & Drive) | 0.79x (vs 1.14x) | Normal wear | 1.25x |
| No keys | 0.80x | Rear end only | 1.16x |
| Airbags deployed | 0.82x |
Rollover at 0.54x and Burn at 0.60x are the cars almost nobody bids on; if you can judge the shell from photos, the biggest discount is there. Hail at 1.66x and minor scratches at 1.37x are the market's dearest labels. A clean title costs 1.24–1.59x; we cover US title types and damage codes separately. Non-repairable and Certificate of Destruction sit at 0.53–0.81x, but such a car cannot be registered.
Models with the widest spread
The widest price spread, i.e. the most mispricing, is in the BMW 3 Series, Acura TLX, Jeep Cherokee, Chevrolet Impala, Jeep Compass, Subaru Forester, Audi A4, Chevrolet Cruze and VW Passat. The tightest is in the RAV4, CR-V, Tesla, Tacoma, 4Runner and Highlander: everyone bids on those, and they do not go cheap. Per-model price distributions are on our sold prices pages.
A buyer's checklist
- 1Look for lots listed 21 days or longer, above all at IAAI; 28 days or longer is better still.
- 2Bid only in live auctions. Buy Now and Timed close above market.
- 3Check the seller: dealer, repo, charity — yes; a large insurer — rarely.
- 4Three or more relists are a signal; one is not. Treat the rejected bid as the floor.
- 5Prefer yards in the Northeast, WV, AL, MI and OH, and IAAI sales on Tuesday–Wednesday mornings.
- 6Do not skip thin listings: read the photos yourself.
- 7Among labels, look for Rollover, Burn, All Over, Stationary and no keys; do not overpay for Hail, minor scratches and theft recovery.
- 8Before bidding, total the full cost in the fee calculator: a discount on the lot will not cover shipping from Hawaii.
How we counted
150,554 sold automobiles of model year 2010 and newer, 72 high-volume models, sold 25 August to 4 October 2026, from the Copart and IAAI sale history. After cleaning (USD, USA, price $300–150,000) 143,989 remained. Gradient-boosted regression on the log of price from make, model, year, trim, odometer, fuel, drive, transmission, engine, body, primary and secondary damage, run status, keys, airbags, title, odometer brand, site, colour, ACV, repair estimate and vehicle score; out-of-fold predictions. A stratified subsample of 3,000 lots (1,500 deals and 1,500 others) was re-read from the detail page for relist history and photo counts. A classifier on pre-sale data reaches AUC 0.73: its top 5% by score sold at 0.83x with a 30% deal rate.
Caveats
- Six weeks of data, mostly September 2026; no seasonality.
- Photos are not modelled, so some "deals" are cars that looked worse than their labels.
- Listing age is known for roughly half of the sales.
- Every ratio is a median for its slice, not a forecast for one lot.
Rebuild these slices yourself in the NotedCar sold-car archive: sold prices, every earlier attempt of a VIN, full photos, 360° and engine video, and market-wide filters including seller type. For one live lot, a registered user sees a free lot report with the lot's earlier attempts under other lot numbers.
Test any slice against real sales: prices, earlier attempts, photos, a seller-type filter.
Open the sale archive