Copart rejected bid: why it is the floor of the price, not the ceiling
The seller turned down the bid and the lot came back. The attempt chains of 2,000 random VINs show the next sale closes at a median 25% above the rejected bid, and only 11% of cars sell below it.

A car relisted after a rejected bid sells at a median 25% above that bid. Only 11% go for less. We checked the attempt chains of 2,000 random VINs sold 19–23 October 2026 and counted what happens after "not sold".
What a rejected bid and a relist are
In a Copart or IAAI live auction the seller has a reserve. If the high bid does not reach it, the lot closes with a status such as "not sold" or "on approval" (the bid is sent to the seller for approval), and the seller either accepts it later or lists the car again, usually under the same lot number, less often under a new one. That is how one VIN's chain of attempts arises. The sale formats are described in our guide to Copart sale types.
Buyers often read the earlier rejected bid as a ceiling: "the seller got no more than $1,600, so it is not worth more than that". The data says the opposite.
How often sold cars had failed attempts
28% of sold cars had at least one failed attempt in the 90 days before the sale: 21% at Copart, 39% at IAAI. 7% had three or more. So more than one sold lot in four is a relist, and at IAAI it is close to two in five.
Final price relative to the rejected bid
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Cars with a failed attempt in the 90 days before the sale | 28% (Copart 21%, IAAI 39%) |
| Three or more failed attempts | 7% |
| Final price vs the last rejected bid, median | 1.25x (+$400 on a median $1,600 rejected bid) |
| Sold below the rejected bid | 11% |
| Finished in a live auction | 1.14x; 18% below the bid |
| Finished through Buy Now | 1.38x; 1% below the bid |
| 3–4 failed attempts: price vs comparable cars | 0.85–0.90x; 36–41% sold at ≤0.75x (n=81) |
| Appeared under more than one lot number | 4.6% |
| Appeared at both Copart and IAAI | 1.9% |
| Sold at auction before | 4.6% (median 14 months earlier; now at 0.55x that price) |
The median rejected bid in the sample was $1,600; the median final price was $400 above it. Where the car was eventually bought in a live auction, the finish was a median 1.14x and 18% of sales fell below the bid. Where it went through Buy Now, 1.38x, and only 1% below the bid: a seller who rejects a bid lists Buy Now above it, not below. The wider six-week sample of 144,000 sales says the same: relists close 13–21% above the rejected bid.
When there are three or four attempts
There is one exception, and it matters. Cars with 3–4 failed attempts sold at 0.85–0.90x comparable cars, and 36–41% of them at 0.75x or less (81 such cars in the sample). Repeated relisting is a signal; a single relist is not. In our breakdown of lots that sell below market, that signal is on the checklist.
A new lot number, the other site, an earlier sale
Only 4.6% of VINs appeared under more than one lot number, and only 1.9% appeared at both Copart and IAAI. Moving a car to the other site happens, but it is not common. Another 4.6% of cars had been sold at auction before, a median 14 months earlier, and this time went for 0.55x the earlier price.
The market that week
Over 19–23 October 2026 the two sites sold 85,668 cars for $345.8M; the median price was $2,000. Copart sold 52,732, IAAI 32,936. Titles: salvage 65%, "Other" 21%, clean 13%; Run & Drive 68%, Stationary 24%. The buyer's country was disclosed on 79% of sales (Copart 92%, IAAI 57%); 77% of cars went to US buyers.
Cars that look the same on paper sell for very different money. In 221 groups with 10 or more sales of the same make, model, year, trim, damage, title and run status, the 90th-percentile price was a median 2.28x the 10th; in 90% of groups at least 1.5x. One pair: two 2023 Honda Civic Sport, front end, salvage, Run & Drive, 55–56k miles, at $3,200 at IAAI in Minnesota and $9,300 at Copart in Georgia. Buy Now that week closed at 1.10x comparable cars, Timed at 1.12x, live auctions at 0.99x; the share sold at ≤0.75x was 24% in auctions, 13% in Buy Now and 11% in Timed. Per-model prices are on our sold prices pages.
Ukrainian buyers
Ukrainian buyers took 663 cars (1.0%) for $5.1M, median $5,800 against $2,000 market-wide. On average they paid the same as everyone else: 1.00x comparable cars against 0.99x for the rest. But on five of their ten most-bought models, the Audi Q5, BMW X3, VW Jetta, Volvo XC90 and Ford Escape (112 cars), Ukrainian buyers paid 1.12x comparable cars while US buyers paid 0.92x. On the Q5 (47 cars): 1.15x against 0.91x, roughly $580 per car more than comparable cars. On the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y, VW Tiguan and Nissan Rogue there is no gap. A selection effect is possible, since Ukrainian buyers may pick cleaner cars within a model, which is why we say "paid more than comparable cars", not "overpaid".
How to use this
- 1Treat the rejected bid as the floor. If the seller refused $1,600, planning on $1,400 is close to pointless: only 11% of chains end that way.
- 2In a live auction, count on 1.14x the rejected bid, and read a Buy Now after a relist as a price above the bid, not below it.
- 3Look for three or more failed attempts: that is where 36–41% of sales go for 0.75x comparable cars.
- 4Check whether the car has been sold before: 4.6% of VINs are a repeat sale, a median 14 months on and at 0.55x.
- 5Compare with the same cars, not with one bid: a 2.28x spread means a single figure says little on its own.
Where to see a VIN's attempt chain
For a live lot, a registered NotedCar user opens a free lot report: it shows the car's earlier attempts, including those under other lot numbers. For cars already sold there is the sale archive at $12 a month in the Car search plan: sold prices, every earlier attempt of a VIN, full photos, 360° and engine video, and market-wide filters including seller type. NotedCar does not flag "deals" automatically; the numbers above are for you to apply. Saved searches with alerts for new lots by email, push and Telegram are on the Car search plan ($12 a month, 7 days free).
How we counted
85,668 cars with status Sold at Copart and IAAI over 19–23 October 2026, from the sale history; for 2,000 random VINs among them, the full chain of attempts. A "comparable car" is an out-of-fold gradient-boosting prediction from make, model, year, trim, odometer, damage, title, run status, keys, drive, fuel, site and yard state (R² 0.86, median error 25%), so the ratios compare a sale with cars that look the same on paper. Every ratio is a median. One week of data, no seasonality.
See every attempt of any VIN: the bids that failed and the price the car finally sold for.
Open the sale archive